Botanicals are the cheapest upgrade you can make to a shrimp tank. A handful of dried cones, a piece of cholla wood and a leaf or two give shrimp something to graze, something to hide in and a surface for biofilm to grow on. Babies in particular spend most of their day picking at that film. Our Indian almond leaves roundup already covers catappa, so this page covers everything else: alder cones, cholla wood and edible leaf litter.
Shrimp-safe status. All eight picks are plain plant material, so there are no copper salts or medications involved. That said, “natural” is not the same as “inert.” Anything harvested outdoors can carry dust, pesticides or residue, so rinse every piece, boil what the seller says to boil, and never use botanicals collected from a roadside, a lawn or a treated garden. Loose cones and leaves also rot if you overdo them, so add a little at a time.
We picked these eight by comparing seller-stated specs, pack counts, preparation instructions and owner reports on live Amazon listings. We have not run lab tests on tannin output, so treat dosing advice as a starting point and watch your own tank.
| SunGrow Alder Cones 50-Pack Best Value Alder Cones | Awesome Aquatic 25 Alder Cones Best Mid-Size Pack | Liquid Gardens Alder Cones 25-Pack Alder Cone Alternate | Awesome Aquatic Staghorn Cholla Wood Tubes 3-Pack, 6 Inch Best Cholla Wood | SunGrow Shrimp Cholla Wood 3-Pack, 6 Inch Best Budget Cholla | SoShrimp Natural Cholla Wood 3-Pack, 4 Inch Best Short Cholla Pieces | MAHYIM Dried Mulberry Leaves 10g (10-15 Leaves) Best Edible Leaf Litter | Awesome Aquatic Betta Shrimp Habitat Kit Best Starter Variety Kit | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Rating | 8.6/10 | 8.4/10 | 8/10 | 9/10 | 8.2/10 | 7.9/10 | 8.1/10 | 8.7/10 |
| Price | $6.60-$6.95as of Nov 15, 2026 | $7.19-$7.99as of Nov 15, 2026 | $7.59-$7.99as of Nov 15, 2026 | $11.49as of Nov 15, 2026 | $7.95as of Nov 15, 2026 | $8.95as of Nov 15, 2026 | $12.99as of Nov 15, 2026 | $18.99-$19.99as of Nov 15, 2026 |
| Type | Alder cones | Alder cones | Alder cones | Cholla wood tubes | Cholla wood | Cholla wood | Dried mulberry leaves | — |
| Count | 50 pieces | 25 pieces | 25 pieces | 3 pieces | 3 pieces | 3 pieces | 10-15 leaves (10 g) | — |
| Size | 0.5-1 inch | 0.5-1 inch | — | — | — | — | — | — |
| Best For | Multi-tank shrimp rooms | — | Single shrimp tank or betta tank | — | — | — | — | Trying every botanical type at once |
| Suggested Dose | — | 1-3 cones per gallon (seller) | — | — | — | — | — | — |
| Length | — | — | — | 6 inches each | 6 inches each | 4 inches each | — | — |
| Treatment | — | — | — | Untreated, thorn-free (seller) | — | — | — | — |
| Prep | — | — | — | — | Soak in hot or boiling saltwater, then sun-dry (seller) | Rinse, boil 15-20 minutes, soak 24-48 hours (seller) | — | — |
| Use | — | — | — | — | — | — | Grazing leaf and supplemental food | — |
| Compatible | — | — | — | — | — | — | Neocaridina, Caridina, Amano, snails | — |
| Leaves | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | 10 catappa, 10 mulberry, 10 dadap |
| Cones | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | 10 alder, 10 casuarina |
| Extras | — | — | — | — | — | — | — | 10 g catappa bark, one 1-6 inch cholla piece |
| Check Price → | Check Price → | Check Price → | Check Price → | Check Price → | Check Price → | Check Price → | Check Price → |
Prices change daily — tap Check Price for the current Amazon price. Numbers shown were verified on the "as of" date.
Quick Picks
Buying Guide: What Each Botanical Does
Alder Cones
Alder cones are small woody catkins that release tannins slowly and develop biofilm on their rough, ridged surface. Shrimp pick at them constantly. Sellers describe a mild softening effect on water, which is plausible given the tannins, but the effect is small and should never be relied on to move pH or KH in a buffered tank. If you run Caridina, use proper pH buffers and buffering substrate for that job and treat cones as a food-and-habitat item. For Neocaridina, cones are low risk because the species tolerates a wide range.
Dose conservatively. One cone per two to three gallons is a sensible starting point for a shrimp tank, even though one seller suggests up to three per gallon. You can always add more.
Cholla Wood
Cholla is the dried skeleton of a cactus, a light, porous, hollow wood. Shrimp climb it, hide in it and graze on the biofilm that grows on it. Unlike dense driftwood it breaks down in a few months, which is the point: it is a consumable. It floats at first, so boil it or soak it until it sinks, or wedge it under a rock. Moss tied onto cholla is a classic way to give shrimplets a nursery. Our moss shrimp tanks roundup shows tank setups built around that idea.
Edible Leaf Litter
Leaf litter such as mulberry is both habitat and food. The leaf softens over a day or two, then shrimp graze it down over several days. It is the botanical most likely to foul water if left too long, so pull what is left after a few days. It is a supplement, not a staple: pair it with a proper staple from our shrimp food guide.
Preparation and Sourcing
- Rinse everything under tap water, then use dechlorinated water for soaking.
- Boil cholla and cones when the listing says so. It helps them sink, removes dust and leaches out the first heavy burst of tannins.
- Avoid pesticide risk. Buy from sellers that sell for aquarium use and state sourcing, and do not substitute garden or craft-store material.
- Start small. Add botanicals gradually and watch for cloudy water or a bacterial film. Remove any piece that turns slimy, smells off or gets covered in a fuzzy white film that does not get eaten within a few days. A little white fuzz at first is usually harmless fungus feeding on the new wood, and shrimp tend to clear it.
Pack Size and Cost per Piece
For a breeder running several tanks, count matters more than looks. The 50-cone pack works out cheaper per cone than the 25-cone packs. Among cholla options, the 4-inch pack is a better fit for jars and nanos, while 6-inch pieces are better for 10-gallon tanks and up. If you are unsure which botanicals your colony prefers, the variety kit is the cheap way to find out before buying a bulk pack. For more on stocking a full setup, see the shrimp breeding setup guide and shrimp substrate roundup.
Detailed Reviews
SunGrow Alder Cones 50-Pack
SunGrow Alder Cones 50-Pack
Best Value Alder Cones- ✓ Largest cone count for the money, enough to stock several tanks
- ✓ Small cones suit nano tanks and breeding jars
- ✓ Listing gives clear rinse-and-boil prep directions
- ✗ Cone size varies from piece to piece
- ✗ Needs a rinse or brief boil before use
The SunGrow pack is the one we would buy for a fish room. Fifty cones at roughly half an inch to an inch each stocks several tanks, and the small size works in nano tanks without dominating the layout. The listing also tells you to rinse the cones and offers a post-boil option, which is the right way to start. Expect natural variation in size, which is normal for a collected product. Shrimp-safe: plain alder cones with no listed additives.
Awesome Aquatic 25 Alder Cones
Awesome Aquatic 25 Alder Cones
Best Mid-Size Pack- ✓ Seller states USA-collected cones
- ✓ 25 count is plenty for one or two tanks
- ✓ Seller gives a per-gallon starting dose
- ✗ Per-cone cost is higher than the 50-pack
- ✗ Seller's dose is aggressive for small tanks, start lower
This is the mid-size alternative if 50 cones is more than you need. The seller states the cones are collected in the USA and are the same half-inch to one-inch size as the SunGrow pack. The seller suggests one to three cones per gallon, which is more than most shrimp tanks need. Start with one cone per few gallons and scale up. Shrimp-safe: no additives are listed, so the usual rinse is all the prep these need.
Liquid Gardens Alder Cones 25-Pack
Liquid Gardens Alder Cones 25-Pack
Alder Cone Alternate- ✓ Same 25-count size as the Awesome Aquatic pack
- ✓ Simple drop-in use
- ✓ Priced in line with other 25-count packs
- ✗ Listing gives no cone size or origin
- ✗ Little preparation guidance from the seller
A straightforward 25-count pack that does the same job. The listing is light on detail, with no stated cone size or origin, so it earns the alternate spot rather than a top pick. It is a reasonable buy if the other two are out of stock. Rinse and boil as you would any alder cone. Shrimp-safe: nothing but dried cones is listed, with no coatings or treatments mentioned.
Awesome Aquatic Staghorn Cholla Wood Tubes 3-Pack, 6 Inch
Awesome Aquatic Staghorn Cholla Wood Tubes 3-Pack, 6 Inch
Best Cholla Wood- ✓ Seller states untreated with no added fertilizers or pesticides
- ✓ Hollow tubes give shrimplets real hiding space
- ✓ Good surface for tying moss or plants
- ✗ Highest price of the three cholla packs
- ✗ Floats until waterlogged
This is the cholla we would pick. The seller states the wood is untreated with no added fertilizers or pesticides and is thorn-free. The hollow tube shape gives baby shrimp real cover, and it takes moss or plants well when tied on with thread. It costs more than the other two cholla packs, but for a nursery tank the sourcing statement is worth it. Shrimp-safe: untreated cactus wood, but boil and soak it before use.
SunGrow Shrimp Cholla Wood 3-Pack, 6 Inch
SunGrow Shrimp Cholla Wood 3-Pack, 6 Inch
Best Budget Cholla- ✓ Lowest price per piece of the cholla options
- ✓ Soft, porous wood that shrimp graze on
- ✓ Easy to cut down for smaller tanks
- ✗ Seller's prep includes a saltwater soak, which adds a step
- ✗ Listing says less about sourcing than the Awesome Aquatic pack
The budget pick. The same six-inch length at the lowest price of the three cholla packs. The seller recommends a hot saltwater soak followed by drying before the wood goes in the tank, so rinse the salt out well afterward and use fresh dechlorinated water for the final soak. Cut it to length with shears for smaller tanks. Shrimp-safe: natural cactus wood, provided you rinse off any saltwater residue.
SoShrimp Natural Cholla Wood 3-Pack, 4 Inch
SoShrimp Natural Cholla Wood 3-Pack, 4 Inch
Best Short Cholla Pieces- ✓ Short pieces fit nano tanks and breeding jars
- ✓ Brand focused on shrimp keeping
- ✓ Seller gives full boil-and-soak steps
- ✗ Shorter pieces offer fewer hides per stick
- ✗ Longer prep time before use
The four-inch pieces are the right size for breeding jars, 5-gallon tanks and nano setups where a six-inch tube looks oversized. The seller recommends a 15-20 minute boil and a 24-48 hour soak, so plan ahead. With only three short pieces, buy two packs for anything bigger than a nano. Shrimp-safe: natural cactus wood with no listed additives.
MAHYIM Dried Mulberry Leaves
MAHYIM Dried Mulberry Leaves 10g (10-15 Leaves)
Best Edible Leaf Litter- ✓ Whole leaves that soften and become grazing surface
- ✓ Listing names both Neocaridina and Caridina as suitable
- ✓ Easy to tear into portions for nano tanks
- ✗ Small pack for the price
- ✗ Uneaten leaf must be removed before it fouls the water
Mulberry is the leaf-litter pick because it is sold specifically as a food and grazing leaf, with Neocaridina, Caridina and Amano shrimp all named as suitable on the listing. Tear a leaf into pieces for a nano tank, or drop it in whole for a larger colony. It is a small pack for the price, and the seller advises removing uneaten material, so this is the one to use sparingly. Shrimp-safe: plain dried leaf, no additives listed.
Awesome Aquatic Betta Shrimp Habitat Kit
Awesome Aquatic Betta Shrimp Habitat Kit
Best Starter Variety Kit- ✓ Covers leaves, cones, bark and cholla in one order
- ✓ Good way to learn which botanicals your shrimp graze
- ✓ Includes mulberry and dadap leaves that are hard to find alone
- ✗ Only 10 of each item, so not a bulk buy
- ✗ Cholla piece is a single sample
The kit bundles catappa, mulberry and dadap leaves, alder and casuarina cones, catappa bark and a piece of cholla. At this price it is the cheapest way to learn which botanicals your colony actually grazes before committing to bulk packs. It is not a bulk buy, with only ten of each item, but as a first order it beats buying five separate products. Shrimp-safe: all plant material with no additives listed.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are alder cones safe for shrimp?
Yes, plain alder cones are widely used in Neocaridina and Caridina tanks. Rinse them first, boil them if the seller recommends it, and avoid any cones collected near treated land. Shrimp graze on the biofilm that grows on them.
How many alder cones should I use?
Start with one cone per two to three gallons and watch the water for a few days. Some sellers suggest up to three per gallon, but that is a lot for shrimp tanks. Add more only if the cones are being picked clean and the water stays clear.
How long does cholla wood last in an aquarium?
Cholla is soft and porous, so it typically breaks down in a few months and is replaced as it crumbles. Owners often report faster breakdown in warm tanks. Treat it as a consumable.
Why does my cholla wood float?
Dry cholla is full of air. Boiling and soaking it waterlogs the wood so it sinks. A rock or a small piece of slate can hold it down in the meantime.
Do botanicals lower pH?
Tannins can soften water a little, but the effect is modest and unreliable in tanks with any real KH. Do not use botanicals to adjust Caridina parameters. Use a buffering substrate and measure with a decent TDS meter or a digital pH meter.
Can I leave botanicals in the tank forever?
No. Once a piece turns to mush, remove it. Cones last longest, cholla lasts months, and leaves are gone within a week or two. Replace them on a schedule rather than waiting for them to foul the water.
Can I use leaves from my yard?
We do not recommend it. Garden leaves can carry pesticides, herbicides or road residue that are deadly to shrimp. Stick to botanicals sold for aquarium use, and rinse them before adding.
Conclusion
For a working shrimp room, buy the SunGrow Alder Cones 50-Pack for biofilm and tannins at the lowest cost per cone, and the Awesome Aquatic Staghorn Cholla Wood Tubes for nursery hides. Those two cover most of what shrimp want from botanicals, and both are cheap enough to replace regularly.
The runner-up is the Awesome Aquatic Betta Shrimp Habitat Kit if you are new to botanicals and want one order that covers leaves, cones, bark and cholla. Add the MAHYIM Mulberry Leaves when you want an edible leaf for the colony, and use them sparingly.
Whatever you buy, rinse it, add it slowly and remove what breaks down. Botanicals support a healthy tank, but they do not replace stable parameters, a good staple food and regular maintenance.
Our Top Pick